
“We are totally arrogant to think we alone have a totally original mind. We are carried on the backs of all writers/artists who came before us. We live in the present with all the history, ideas and soda pop of this time. It all gets mixed up in our writing/art.” -Natalie Goldberg
“All art is infested by other art.” -Leo Steinberg
Is my idea original? Am I the first person ever to make this form or paint this image? What makes what I do ‘my art.’ And should originality be the goal or be viciously defended?
I find even if two people are given the same materials and instructions to create something and go into separate rooms to make their piece, each piece would be vastly different.
I think it’s healthy to have this discussion frequently because just this week it’s come up again for me in a big way. Last spring I was accused of not making my own work in clay by another blogger and I’ve just learned this same artist is doing it again to another blogger. I think it is troublesome if someone is copying your work exactly for profit. I know this is an ongoing problem for some artists. That’s not what I’m talking about here.
Why would someone want to copy? Because if our only goal is to replicate, we end up restraining our own essence from coming through. But using inspiration as reference – giving ourselves permission to shift and change it verses copying – allows our own stories to emerge – our own unique way of interpreting what we see around us. What makes work great or powerful is that passion showing through. And it’s what artists do – recreate – interpret what they see around them.
So is an ‘authentic-original’ voice the goal? And if so how do we achieve that originality? Does just the act of learning technique and going into our studios and getting to work invite originality no matter what the inspiration? Does a disciplined work ethic keep that ‘voice’ intact? Maybe it’s a combination of inspiration and work. I do believe if you really know how to manipulate your materials, honor those materials and honor your creativity — you will make your work.
And in that finally comes confidence. Because I really believe when someone lashes out, they are suffering a lack of confidence and feel threatened that their work won’t be as good as someone else doing something similar. But I’m going to tell you if every time I paint and I only use red, can I then accuse all other artists who use the color red of copying my work? This situation is just that simple. We all use color and form successfully in lots of wonderfully different but similar ways. What then makes it original?
And in this time of the internet bringing us all closer and filling our heads with everyone else’s art and all of the workshops available – how do we stay true to ourselves? And how do we discourage folks from stealing our ideas or accusing us of stealing their ideas? Or how do we keep from inadvertently stealing others ideas?
I also read on a blog this week someone upset by having someone use an image from their blog on Pinterest. Copyright laws certainly need to change and adapt to this internet growth. It’s here to stay. One of my images was ‘pinned’ but I took it as a complement. Isn’t marketing or to have our work be seen one of the reasons we have our work online?
What do you think? And do you think any of this is even a problem? Have you been affected by any of this and how did you deal with it?
“Even in literature and art, no man who bothers about originality will ever be original; whereas if you simply try to tell the truth (without caring twopence how often it has been told before) you will, nine times out of ten, become original without ever having noticed it.” -C.S. Lewis
“The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources.” -Albert Einstein